Spray skirts are a kayaking accessory generally reserved for more experienced paddlers that traverse rougher waters. The only problem is that if you ever decide that you want to learn how to roll a kayak as a casual paddler, you may want to know whether or not this accessory is required for this maneuver.
You can roll a kayak without a spray skirt. Executing a successful kayak roll has to do more with technique and skill rather than paddling accessories. Spray skirts may prove useful for rolling, but they weren’t primarily designed for that purpose.
Kayakers have been performing rolls in the water long before the spray skirt was even developed. However, as time has gone by, people have slowly fallen for the notion that spray skirts are an essential piece of equipment to the kayak roll. Having said that, let’s delve more into the exact reasoning behind why you can roll without a skirt.
Why You Can Roll a Kayak Without a Skirt
Any paddler can make a mistake and end up capsizing their kayak, regardless of what kayak they may have or what water conditions they’re traveling.
For this reason, it’s a critical skill to know exactly what to do if you ever do fall into the water so that you can take care of your safety. One of the most common ways that kayakers handle a capsize is the kayak roll.
In case you weren’t aware, the term “roll” in the kayaking community refers to a maneuver that allows a paddler to quickly flip their kayak back over without ever having to leave their seat. It is done with a quick and sudden jerk of the hip, creating enough bodily momentum to propel the entire kayak up to a 180-degree turn. The result is that the kayaker is put back in its original position, up and out of the water (source).
As aforementioned, it is a widely held belief that you can only do a roll if you have a spray skirt on your kayak. As a quick reference, a spray skirt is an accessory that you add to the kayak’s cockpit to lock yourself in place while also protecting the cockpit from getting flooded or wet.
You can see exactly what a kayak looks like and learn more about its functions by clicking over to Kayak Spray Skirts: What They Are & How They’re Used.
With all this background information introduced, let’s move on to why a skirt is not necessarily the most important part of doing the roll.
Spray Skirts Prevent Flooding, Not Rolling
Before people even realized how useful the spray skirt is for doing the roll, the primary reason why it was developed was to prevent flooding in the cockpit. So in that sense, it was never developed to roll.
When you’re kayaking, it’s normal for water to get into the cockpit. For example, the act of paddling naturally splashes water into the kayak. Falling rainwater is yet another common way that water can pool within the kayak’s cockpit.
With water being able to access a kayak’s interior in such a variety of ways, you have to take steps to protect the kayak’s interior from flooding. Otherwise, you run the risk of adding unnecessary difficulty to your kayaking experience.
Plus, you also have to consider just how cold the water and the weather can be while you’re kayaking. You wouldn’t want the frigid water or the chilly weather to distract you from kayaking.
In both cases, the spray skirt proves useful because it basically acts like an umbrella. It surrounds the cockpit, keeping the kayak’s interior and your lower body from being exposed to the elements.
Slightly Flooded Kayaks are Easier to Tip Over
As mentioned earlier, we know that the spray skirt is useful for protecting the kayak’s interior from flooding. But, you also have to understand that flooded kayaks are easier to tip over.
When you perform the hip jerk, the weight of the floodwater helps to rock the kayak in the direction you want to go. This extra “push” of the flood water helps to finish off the roll so that you can put yourself back in the upright position.
Of course, this benefit also comes at the expense of inherent instability in maintaining that upright position. So even if you do manage to roll yourself back up, there’s a good chance that you could plunge back underwater if the water sloshes around too much.
Essentially, it’s a give and take. Most kayakers opt to go with the spray skirt nowadays because they also don’t want to deal with the prospect of potentially sinking their kayak underwater.
Lack of Confinement May Help Eliminate Fear
While we’ve already touched on the usefulness of the spray skirt, it’s important to understand that there’s a good reason why some kayakers prefer to kayak without one.
Let’s go back to how a spray skirt works. You are basically wearing a skirt that wraps around your waist while acting as an umbrella that’s attached to the kayak. As such, it keeps you confined to the kayak unless you loosen the waistband around you (source).
This restriction of mobility may induce fear in paddlers that are inexperienced because they don’t like the feeling of being confined in the water.
Plus, if you happen to capsize while wearing a spray skirt and you’re not intimately familiar with how to roll, this fear might cause you to freeze. Obviously, being frozen with fear would cause a lot of trouble during your attempt to resurface for air.
The Problems with Rolling a Kayak Without a Skirt
You can indeed roll a kayak without using a spray skirt. Nevertheless, there are still problems you will inevitably encounter if you do choose to roll a kayak without the help of a spray skirt.
Harder to Maintain Control Over a Flooded Kayak
It’s a simple fact that flooded kayaks are more difficult to control. The water trapped in the cockpit interferes with paddling stability and weighs the kayak down.
Consequently, it will likely be much more challenging to keep the kayak stable while you’re on the water, to the point where the risk of capsizing increases considerably. Even if you could still roll the kayak in the event of a capsize, the risk of flipping over again is much greater in comparison to when you’re wearing a spray skirt.
Interior Water Can Make Your Legs Cold
We have also talked about how a spray skirt is there not only to keep water out of the cockpit, but also to protect your lower body from the cold weather. When both the air and water are cold enough, your legs inevitably end up feeling cold as well. The shivering that results from this can affect the stability as well as your concentration.
Not only that, but severely cold weather or water could cause the onset of hypothermia. Shockingly, hypothermia can set in with water temperatures as high as 60 to 70 ℉, or 15.5 to 21℃ (source).
Under these circumstances, you need all the layers that you can get to combat hypothermic conditions. Once cold water finds its way into your kayak, it can be tough to remove.
Constant contact with freezing water and the greater risk of hypothermia will almost certainly detract from your ability to roll a kayak. Plus, it won’t be nearly as enjoyable!
Skirt or No Skirt: Which Is Better for Rolling?
To reiterate, it’s much easier to perform a kayak roll when you have a spray skirt on. This is mostly because the waistband around the kayaker’s waist confines them to the kayak comfortably and securely. By doing so, the space around the kayaker is minimized as the skirt is connected to the kayak’s cockpit. This allows the kayaker to easily flip the kayak back to an upright position with a powerful hip jerk.
The only problem you will encounter when using a spray skirt is confinement, which can provoke feelings of fear and panic if you do end up capsizing.
However, if you have gotten over the fear of confinement, then it’s a different discussion entirely. Once you weigh the positives of using a spray skirt with its downsides, you will realize that it’s far better to kayak with a skirt because of all of its added benefits. On top of how it protects you from the elements, it makes rolling much easier to execute.
All things considered, you can roll with or without a spray skirt on your kayak. That’s because rolling a kayak is a matter of skill, technique, and experience rather than a product of the spray skirt. So whether you should wear a spray skirt or not for rolling is ultimately up to you.